From the late 1700s to the mid-1800s, the
Fullerton area found itself the object of those hoping to profit from its
resources or pass through its rich prairies. French traders, migrating
Mormons, and hopeful settlers came and went as fortune favored or abandoned
them. A treaty in 1856 made Nance County and some nearby counties into a
Pawnee reservation. An Indian school was built in a nearby town, and
villages were established near the present site of Fullerton.
The increased military presence and
government attention brought focus to the area's potential. After the
Civil War, displaced citizens, immigrants, and entrepreneurs advanced in waves
across the plains along with the transcontinental railroad, hoping to get rich
or at least gain a new start. Nance County could not be settled by the
provisions of the Homestead Act because it was an Indian reservation; however,
sod houses popped up all around in neighboring territory.
In July 1876, Randall Fuller, en-route with a
large herd of cattle from Faribault, Minnesota, to Colorado was so impressed
with the lush prairies, two rivers to reduce risk of prairie fire, and many
other features of the country that he decided to locate and establish his
future headquarters here. Others made the same discovery, and the economic
boom took on a life of its own.
Demonstrating his foresight, Fuller purchased
large tracts of land when the Indian reservation was taken away from the Native
Americans. In 1871 after the Pawnee had been transferred to Oklahoma, the
land was auction "to benefit the Indians." A minimum bid of
$2.50 per acre was set. Fuller bought choice segments of land between the
Loup and Cedar Rivers and immediately set out to have the town
surveyed. By 1879, a system of streets marked only by stakes existed, and
Fullerton was named the temporary county seat, pending organization of a county
government. Fuller donated 60 acres of land to the county to build a
courthouse.
Fuller faced stiff competition from another
entrepreneur, D.A. Willard of Genoa, who wanted his land to be the county seat.
Considerable economic incentives and land values were at stake. Fuller
craftily proposed the new county be named Nance, after the then governor of the
state, and that Fullerton be the county seat. A similar proposal from
Willard was to name the county Willard, with Genoa as the county seat. It is
not known if Governor Nance was swayed by the flattering application, but the
results of a disputed election along with the governor's intervention allowed
Fullerton to earn the honor.
The area's hunting and fishing opportunities
have been a part of the local heritage. A museum in an early church provides a
more detailed look at other elements of the proud history, people, and
potential of Fullerton.
One of the most picturesque spots in the area
is located in the northwest corner of Fullerton and has been referred to as
"Buffalo Leap" (Indians drove buffalo off the cliff as a hunting
technique) and more commonly as "Lovers Leap" or simply "The
Leap." Randall Fuller purchased the 40 plus acres of oak timber and
made it available to others. It served as the location of the Chautauqua for
nearly thirty years from 1898 to 1930. In the heyday of the Chautauqua, special
trains were dispatched from Columbus to bring people to the two-week event that
featured political candidates, musicians, evangelists, lecturers, nationally
known entertainers, and even the full three-ring Barnum and Bailey
Circus. The town's population literally doubled during that time, and a
tent city was erected to house the guests. The area also served as a site for
summer homes, as a "tourist camp," and has been the site of the
Nebraska Baptist Camp since 1941. Now known as "Broken Arrow Wilderness,"
it still offers recreational opportunities and social facilities for the
public. Broken Arrow Wilderness was the home of the first official state
4th of July celebration held in 1844.